"Cooking for Two" cookbook.

The Power of Simplicity: Janet Hill, Fannie Farmer, and Perfect Recipes a Century Later

In her late thirties, high school teacher Janet McKenzie Hill ventured to Boston, where she enrolled at the Boston Cooking School. After studying under American culinary pioneer Fannie Farmer, then director of the BCS, Hill graduated in 1892. She went on to found the Boston Cooking School Journal, which she edited for many years, and author numerous cookbooks, including Salads, Sandwiches, and Chafing Dish Dainties (1899), Practical Cooking and Serving (1902), and Whys of Cooking (1916) (Feeding America). This recipe for ginger cakes—flavorful spice cookies boasting a crispy exterior and a dense, chewy center akin to soft gingerbread—comes from her 1909 volume Cooking for Two: A Handbook for Young Housekeepers.

Version 2Plain Ginger Cakes

½ cup of molasses

1 teaspoonful of soda

¼ cup of butter

¼ cup of boiling water

2 cups of flour

½ teaspoonful of salt

½ tablespoonful of ginger

½ teaspoonful of cinnamon

Stir the soda into the molasses; melt the butter in the boiling water; turn all into a bowl and stir in the flour, sifted with the salt and spices; add more flour if needed, but keep the dough as soft as can be handled. Roll a little of the dough at a time to a sheet about three-eighths of an inch thick and cut into rounds. Press two pecan nut meats into the top of each, and dredge with granulated sugar. Bake in a moderate oven. The recipe will make about twenty cakes.

In this book and others, Hill, a graduate of the Boston Cooking School under Fannie Farmer’s tenure, exemplifies the style of this landmark figure in American cooking. During her life, Farmer pioneered the idea of indicating exact measurements in recipes, and she sought to re-invigorate the culinary landscape of the average American household through her straightforward yet intriguing recipes. Her approach, diverse but always accessible, made Farmer a celebrity: when she first published her Boston Cooking School Cookbook, more commonly referred to as the Fannie Farmer Cookbook, it sold over three thousand copies in the first year. The book remains in print to this day, with more than four million copies sold (Snodgrass 226).


While Farmer’s recipes featured concrete, precise directions, they by no means served to restrict aspiring home cooks. Rather, with clear and easy-to-follow instructions, they rendered a complete range of cuisine—from sweet potato waffles to barbecued ham to lobster chowder—accessible to any curious reader, regardless of background and experience.

Farmer’s influence on Hill, her student at the Boston Cooking School, is evident in Hill’s Cooking for Two, which features—like Fannie Farmer’s cookbook before it—specific instructions for preparation (including precise measurements) and detailed nutritional advice (Snodgrass 226). Hill also borrows Farmer’s inclusion of sample menus: the book’s appendix contains a week’s worth of meal suggestions (breakfast, lunch, and dinner) for every month of the year, as well as a special section providing holiday options.


This array of information makes Cooking for Two a veritable treasury for the young turn-of-the-century woman: among innumerable other selections, its four hundred pages hold instructions for broiling a simple fish, roasting wild duck with cranberries, assembling a rutabaga-turnip salad, and crafting delectable desserts (caramel ice cream, moist chocolate cake, and the plain ginger cakes which I recreated, to name a few). Though the expectations on housewives in this era could be oppressively intense, Hill utilizes Fannie Farmer’s style of clear, precise directions to open the doors upon countless diverse and exciting recipes, enlivening the daily necessity of preparing food for the family.

4601000979_d352d27646_oDespite the famed accessibility of Farmer and Hill’s approach, I was still, admittedly, pretty apprehensive to try a recipe from 1909. When I ventured to bake my first batch of Hill’s ginger cakes, I fully expected some disaster to engulf my kitchen. However, I was quickly proven wrong. I followed the recipe exactly, measuring and mixing the ingredients according to Hill’s precise instructions, and before long, a flawless batch of ginger cakes materialized.

The directions lack only a specific oven temperature and baking time. However, considering that this recipe comes from an era without today’s built-in oven temperature and timing controls, such an absence is not surprising. I simply interpreted Hill’s “moderate oven” as about 325° and baked the cookies for eight minutes. They emerged from the oven uniform and puffy, their crisp, sugar-coated exteriors revealing a soft, hearty center rich with spicy warmth.

Undoubtedly, the style pioneered by Farmer and advanced by Hill facilitated the ease with which I re-created this 1909 recipe. The specific measurements (cup, teaspoon, tablespoon) remain unchanged by time, and the step-by-step directions guided me painlessly and smoothly through the process—just as they were intended to guide readers at the turn of the twentieth century.

Version 2



Works Cited

Hill, Janet McKenzie. Cooking for Two: A Handbook for Young Housekeepers. Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1909. Print.

Hill, Janet McKenzie.” Feeding America: The Historic American Cookbook Project. Michigan State University Gerald M. Kline Digital and Multimedia Center Digital Collections, 31

August 2003. Web. 19 April 2016. “Janet McKenzie Hill.” Marquis Who’s Who. Marquis Who’s Who LLC, 2016. Web. 21 April 2016.

Magro, Julie. “Measuring Spoons.” Photograph. Flickr. Yahoo, 11 May 2010. Web. 22 April 2016.

Snodgrass, Mary Ellen. Encyclopedia of Kitchen History. New York: Fitzroy Dearborn, 2004. Print.

1903 Boston Cooking School Boylston St. Boston Evening Transcript Feb 21.png.” Photograph. Wikimedia Commons. Wikipedia Foundation, Inc., 6 March 2015. Web. 19 April 2016.

By Annemarie Lisko

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *